Haul Trucks and Ore Sorting Plant

Fixed
iProfessore [github] · 1 year ago

Issue description

Ore Sorting Plant Unsorted space 360
Haul Truck Max. load 180
In theory if unmsorted space is <180 a Haul Truck can unload.
That is not what happens. Haul Trucks always wait until Unsorted space is empty before unloading.
Try any save, it will do that

Reproduction steps

Load any save with Ore Sorter and Haul Trucks
Watch Unsorted space and Haul Trucks unloading

Game version and build number

v0.6.4d b347

Operating system

Windows

iProfessore [github] · 1 year ago

Even Pickups do it.

Surely even if the output of a product is full that does not mean it can't be added to unsorted?

The logic here does not make much sense

storm6436 [github] · 1 year ago

This might be related to what I posted in the steam feedback section earlier, depending on if I'm reading this correctly.

Per current play-through, though, I haven't seen behavior consistent with "wait until buffer empty before delivery" especially with trucks, as I definitely saw multiple deliveries with non-empty buffers. That said, when migrating from 60u trucks to 180u dump trucks, it certainly can appear they wait until the buffer is empty if your mining building is sufficiently far from the sorter due to the fact that deliveries are done serially (ie. building is reserved by a single vehicle, regardless of distance/drive time, and everyone else queues at the mining building until that vehicle delivers)

The serial behavior presents less of a problem with 60u trucks due to travel speed and the ability to structure storage inputs around single-load rejection, but 180u dump trucks are rarely single-load, making 'reject single-load' of questionable utility.

180u dump truck speed exposes the shortcomings of serial delivery behavior over remarkably short distances. Case in point: 1 mega excavator with 10 60u trucks was able to feed 6 T2 blast furnaces in my current play-through, but swapping to 5 180u dump trucks resulted in all trucks but one parked at the mining building waiting their turn to deliver to a sorter reserved solely for their use that sat inactive/idle 90% of the time.

Play-through context: Armageddon map, southern start point. Sorter facility located on cleared ground just south of crater rim copper deposit. Referenced mining operation is at the starting iron deposit, building WSW of the iron deposit. Delivery distance in that case is not terribly far.

Captain Filip Captain Filip · 1 year ago

This has been addressed with the large ore sorting plant, which has much bigger buffers.

Closed as ✅ Fixed

7 Showing 1–4 of 4